Best Roasting Pan: Top 8 Picks for Roaster Pans, including Turkeys

Occasions such as birthdays, anniversaries, and holidays happen all year round. For this reason, you must invest in a good roasting pan to help you prepare savory dishes for every celebration. They come in a wide variety of sizes, materials and designs and it can be a bit overwhelming to find the right one.

Not to worry though, we’ve done the hard work for you and narrowed down the choices to our top picks.

Best Roasting Pans: Top 8 Options

This article provides you with a rundown of our best roasting pans. Keep on reading for all the details you need to know!

#1: Cuisinart Stainless Rectangular Roaster

The Cuisinart Chef’s Classic roaster allows you to cook large food batches effortlessly. The riveted handles help make placing the roaster in and out of the oven safe and free of hassle. Lastly, the steel racks promote heat circulation and allow poultry and meat to drain whilst being cooked.

Important Features:

• Stainless exterior with triple-ply
• Stainless steel riveted handles that make it easy to grip and pick up
• Heavy-duty steel rack that drains fat as it cooks
• Induction-ready cookware
• Dishwasher-safe
• Drip free pouring (ideal for gravy)
• Large enough for turkeys
• Lifetime warranty

Customer Reviews For the Cuisinart Stainless Rectangular Roaster

—>Read More Reviews on Amazon for the Best Roasting Pan<—

“I was able to roast a 23-pound turkey for Thanksgiving with this roaster. Had no problems with the drippings touching the meat and it did a great job. I made the gravy right in the pan too and I loved that I could pour it out without dripping or spilling.”

“It is truly sturdy and reliable. Probably the best roasting pan on the market. I use this, along with my cooking thermometer for perfect roasts.”

“This roaster is very easy to clean and dishwasher-safe too. Seriously, this is kind of a game-changer because who wants to scrub greasy and baked on food out of a pan after a big holiday meal! Nobody, that’s who.”

The Takeaway on The Cuisinart Stainless Rectangular Roaster

What we find exceptional about this product is its guaranteed durability and reliability. Thus, this roaster will definitely last you a solid number of years.

We LOVE companies that stand behind their products and Cuisinart certainly does that, not just with their roasting pan. In this case, they offer a lifetime warranty which is backed by customer service. It’s mainly for this reason that we put this turkey roaster pan at the top of our list.

Shop Now

This roasting pan from Cuisinart is certainly one of our top picks. Click the button below to check it out over on Amazon and don’t forget to see if it’s eligible for fast, free shipping with a Prime membership:

Cuisinart Turkey Roaster Review

Do you want to learn more about this Cuisinart Roasting Pan that’s ideal for turkeys or other large cuts of meat? Then you’ll want to check out this short review video on YouTube for all the details and to see it in action:

#2: Circulon Non-Stick Roaster

Are you looking for a large roaster? The Circulon Non-Stick Roaster offers a hefty pan size that can accommodate up to 24lbs of the roast turkey or other meats. With the roaster’s metal rack, the meat is kept separate from oil and juice drippings as it roasts. Lastly, with its non-stick coating, cleaning this roasting pan is made effortless.

Important Features:

• Extra Large Roaster: 17″ x 13″
• Non-Stick Coating
• Comes with a handy steel rack that is u-shaped (keeps meat off the bottom of the pan)
• Fast heating and even heat distribution
• Oven-safe up to 450°F
• Very durable
• Wide handles for a more confident grip

User Reviews for this Large Roaster:

—>See More Reviews for this Roaster Pan on Amazon.com<—

“This roaster has a good depth which makes it perfect for large roast beefs and turkeys. The second you open the box, the quality is evident with this thing.”

“Because the metal rack is removable, this pan also allows vegetable roasts. It’s such a good roaster for the price and I love the wider handles on it. This makes it easy to take a large turkey out of the oven and not worry about it slipping out of your hands.”

“Although this roasting pan is not dishwasher-safe, it is very easy to clean which is why I like it. It has a nice, non-stick finish so that the oil and food drippings just kind of slide off of it.”

Summary For The Circulon Non-Stick Roaster

Based on the highlighted features and customer reviews we have gathered, this roasting pan, overall, offers good size, functionality, and durability. If you are on the market for an affordable yet highly reliable roaster, we recommend you check this product out.

Get Yours Today

Do you want to pick up your own roaster pan? Head on over to Amazon where you can find the lowest prices:

Compare Roasting Pans with Racks

Do you want to see some of our top picks for roaster pans side-by-side? Then you’ll definitely want to check out this handy comparison chart below:

#3: Chefmade Non-Stick Roasting Pan

The Chefmade Non-Stick Roasting Pan allows you to prepare restaurant-like roasts a lot faster and easier indoors. Moreover, what’s even better about this pan is its resistance to warping. Therefore, you can definitely count on this roaster to last you years.

Important Features:

• Carbon steel allows fast and even heat distribution
• Food-grade silicone non-stick coating (FDA approved)
• High heat-resistance
• Easy to clean
• Warping-resistant
• Durable and reliable for long term use
• Excellent customer service

What Do People Think About It?

—>Read More Roasting Pan Reviews on Amazon<—

“Well-crafted, heavy and reliable pan. Plus, the non-stick feature is such a great added bonus. It’s a great value when you consider the price!”

“I was able to make delicious porchetta with this pan. It only took 40 minutes at 450°F and turned out so well. Don’t forget to get yourself a nice slicing knife too to get the job done in style!”

“I love the quality, the size as well as the color and style of this pan. It’s big enough to fit just about anything you might want to cook in it and I love the removable rack that comes along with it.”

The Takeaway on The Chefmade Non-Stick Roasting Pan

With Chefmade’s Non-stick Roaster, you no longer have to go through the hassle of putting up fire outdoors to get excellent-tasting barbecues and roasts.

Where Can I Find It?

You can easily get this roasting pan online. Check here for the lowest prices on kitchen tools and gadgets:

#4: Calphalon Hard-Anodized Non-Stick Roasting Pan

When talking about quality and craftsmanship, the Calphalon Hard-Anodized Non-Stick Roasting Pan makes the cut for our list of top well-made roasters on the market. This roasting pan features aluminum steel that is hard-anodized which promotes rapid and even heating. Thus, you always get the perfect amount of tenderness for every roast.

Important Features for the Best Turkey Roasting Pan:

• Hard-anodized, non-stick racks, and interiors
• Polished stainless steel handles that are easy to grip and pick up the heavy pan with
• Oven-safe up to 450°F
• Not dishwasher-safe but easy clean up due to the coating on the pan (check out: Best Dish Drying Racks here)
• Comes in standard, or frustration free packaging

Online Reviews for the Calphalon Hard-Anodized Non-Stick Roasting Pan

“This roasting pan from Calphalon has a good size. I was able to fit a 24-pound turkey without any problem and even though you can’t put it into the dishwasher, it’s super easy to clean up.”

“It is very easy to clean by hand and is one of the best turkey roasting pans in my opinion. It’s huge and works well for even the biggest turkeys.”

“Since the rack is removable, I was able to use this pan for making lasagna, it’s a perfect size and the finish is ideal for baked on cheese since it just slides off basically.”

Summary For The Calphalon Hard-Anodized Non-Stick Roasting Pan

In conclusion, we think that the Calphalon hard-anodized roasting pan is an excellent kitchen tool. From the material, design, and functionality, we agree that this roaster will give a good bang for your buck.

Shop Now

Do you want to pick yourself up one of the best turkey roasting pans on the market today? Then you’ll want to head over to Amazon to get it for yourself right here:

#5: Granite Ware Covered Oval Roasting Pan

If you are on the market for a truly reliable roaster that is inexpensive, the Granite Ware Covered Oval Roasting Pan is a product you must check out. This roaster is crafted with carbon steel which makes it incredibly durable and safer to use than foil-type roasting pans.

Important Features:

• 3-quart capacity
• Crafted with carbon steel and porcelain coating
• Non-stick
• Safer to use than foil roasters
• Dishwasher-safe
• Made in the USA
• Browns food well and cooks evenly
• Very reasonably priced
• Durable and long lasting

Customer Reviews:

—>Check out More roaster pan reviews on Amazon<—

“This roaster is so versatile, I use it to make gravy after roasting poultry or meat. It’s kind of old school and doesn’t have any of the fancy finishes on it, but it works well for my needs.”

“It browns the meat perfectly and I love the price. Don’t forget to get yourself a turkey baster too for the best results.”

“It is really non-stick and effortless to clean. I generally just throw mine into the dishwasher when it cools down a little bit. Couldn’t be easier.”

Should You Consider Buying The Granite Ware Covered Oval Roasting Pan?

Although this roasting pan is not as massive as the other ones mentioned above, we think that this product is worth investing in given all its exceptional features.

Where Can I Buy It?

The best place to buy roasting pans is on Amazon. You’ll have the largest selection and also find very competitive prices. Click the button below to find out all the details for yourself right here:

#6: KitchenAid Roasting Pan

Here at Kitchen Gadget Reviews, we love to recommend KitchenAid products. They combine nice, thoughtful design along with top-notch materials and construction. This results in a product that performs well and is built to last a lifetime.

The KitchenAid roasting pan is no exception to this. It’s a great product at a reasonable price and of course, it’s backed by excellent customer service in case you should ever have problems with it.

Important Features

• 3 layers (stainless steel with an aluminum core)
• Big enough to handle large turkeys
• Even heat distribution
• Dishwasher safe
• Space saver handles
• Removable roasting rack
• Broiler and stovetop safe

User Reviews

“Beautiful to use. It’s heavy-duty and I think it’ll last me a lifetime of roasting turkeys and ham! Highly recommended.”

“Okay, so it’s a little bit more expensive, but what you’re getting is a seriously nice product that is well-built. It has a nice finish on it too that’s easy to clean up afterwards.”

Shop Now

Do you want to pick up this top-quality roasting pan for your next big holiday feast? Head over to KitchenAid to find the best prices:

#7: Calphalon Stainless Steel Heavy Bottomed Roasting Pan

If you’re looking for a roasting pan with a very heavy bottom, then this stainless steel one from Calphalon might be your best bet. It’s made from a double layer of stainless steel with an aluminum core and certainly is enough to handle just about anything without burning or scorching.

Keep on reading for all the details you’ll need to know about the Calphalon stainless steel roasting pan and whether or not it’s the right option for you. We think you’ll like yours as much as we like ours.

Key Features 

• Double layer of stainless steel with an aluminum core
• 16 inch roaster pan
• Nonstick rack
• Easy cleaning
• Easy grip, stainless steel handles
• Over and broiler safe
• Lifetime warranty

Customer Reviews

“I mean, it’s tough to go wrong with a product with a lifetime warranty, right? If  you want to get a rectangular roasting pan that’ll last a lifetime, this one from Calphalon is probably it. It’s heavy-duty, which is super obvious from the second that you take this thing out of the box.”

“This is one of the largest roasting pans out there and it can easily handle the biggest hams or turkeys. It’s deep, super heavy on the bottom and the handles are easy to grip and pick up. The brushed stainless steel makes clean up a breeze too. Overall,  a really nice choice and I’d give it 6 stars out of 5 if I could!”

Buy it Today

Do you want to pick up one of our favourite heavy-bottomed roasting pans? This one from Calphalon, although quite expensive is durable enough to last a lifetime. Head over the company’s website to find out all the details you need to know about whether or not it’s the right option for you:

#8: Gibson Home Extra-Large Turkey Roaster Pan

If you’re looking for a very reasonably priced, extra-large turkey roasting pan, then this one from Gibson Home should certainly be at the top of your list. Keep on reading to find out more about why we like this thing so much.

Important Features

• 16.5 inches x 12.5 inches
• 3 inches deep
• Black xylan exterior
• Easy grip handles make picking it up easy
• Nonstick and easy to clean
• Durable carbon steel construction
• Reasonable price

User Reviews for this Turkey Roasting Pan

“Great non-stick pan and rack that seems durable enough and I certainly can’t complain about the price of this thing. It’s an extra-large, deep roasting pan that’s ideal for turkeys, ducks or bigger cuts of beef or pork.”

“Nice turkey pan if you’re only going to use it once a twice a year. It doesn’t seem super durable though if you read the other reviews in terms of the non-stick coating. But, so far, so good for me and it was like 1/3 the price of some of the ridiculously expensive ones so I’m happy enough with it.”

The Takeaway on one of the Largest Roasting Pans

If you’re looking for a large, deep roasting pan that’s ideal for turkeys or other large cuts of meat, then consider this one from Gibson Home. The price is most certainly right, but you do need to be careful with the non-stick coating that can chip or flake off quite easily.

Get this Gibson Home Turkey Roaster Pan Today

This 2-piece turkey roaster is one of the top picks if you’re looking for an extra large turkey roaster pan. Click the button below to head over to Amazon to learn more about it here:

Top 6 Factors to Consider When Buying a Roasting Pan

A good roasting pan allows you to bring out the exceptional flavors of poultry and meat. However, with all the different brands and prices, choosing your best roasting pan can be a bit challenging. This article will break down the top five factors take into account when shopping for a roasting pan.

#1: The Material of The Pan

Roasting pans can be made of cast iron, stainless steel, aluminum, stoneware, and more. However, roasting pans that are made of aluminum are the most common ones.

Aluminum pans are known for being an efficient heat conductor and are also lightweight.

Cast iron roasting pans are typically heavy and conduct heat very well.

Stainless steel pans are easy to clean due to its resistance to marks.

Stoneware roasters are versatile enough for baking cakes and puddings.

#2: The Size and Depth

Ideally, a roasting pan must have a 5cm space on all sides of the meat to ensure the oils and liquids don’t evaporate to avoid drying out the meat.

Of course, if you plan to use your roasting pan for turkey, you must ensure that it’s big enough to handle this. However, the roasting pans on this list are all a good size for even large turkeys so not to worry!

#3: The Racks and Handles

The rack ensures that the oil and juice drippings do not touch the meat as it roasts. This is perfect for roasting turkey or chicken. On the other hand, the handles of the pan allow you to easily and safely put the pan in and out of the oven.

#4: Ease of Cleaning

To ensure ease of cleaning, you must choose a pan that is non-stick as it is easier and quicker to clean. Moreover, remember that not all roasting pans are dishwasher-safe.

We generally prefer ones that are dishwasher safe. Imagine just giving a turkey roaster pan a quick rinse to get the oil off and then throwing it into the dishwasher. Makes life easy, right?

#5: The Price

Roasting pan prices range from $15 up to $80, depending on the size and material. When choosing a roaster, do not just pick one with the best price, consider the four factors mentioned above first.

#6: Customer Reviews

As with anything that you might consider buying, it’s always prudent to check what actual user are saying about the product. In this case, you’ll want to check out the 3-4 star reviews on Amazon to get the most accurate depiction of a product’s true strengths and weaknesses.

Roasting Pan FAQs

There are a number of common questions that people have about roaster pans. Here are the answers to some of the most common ones:

Can Roasting Pans Be Used on the Stovetop?

Some people use roasting pans on the stovetop for making gravy. Thick works well for roaster pans that have thicker bottoms. Thin bottomed roasting pans may warp if used on the stovetop so do so cautiously and on low heat. For gravy, it’s often recommended to pour the drippings into a pot instead.

Are Stainless Steel Roasting Pans Good?

Stainless steel roasting pans are a good options because they’re easy to clean, strong and durable also also resist marking or scuffing. They also create a nice, sticky fond on the bottom which can make delicious gravy iron. Compared to cast iron, stainless steel is equally strong but far lighter.

What Can I Use Instead of a Roasting Pan?

If you don’t have a roasting pan, there are a number of other things you can use instead. Here are some of the alternatives:

• Large cast iron skillet
• Stainless steel skillet
• Large casserole dish or pan
• Broiler pan
• Paella pan
• Large baking sheet with high edges (be careful when taking out of the oven)

What is Considered a Shallow Roasting Pan?

For turkey, a deeper roasting pan of more than 2 inches is recommended because of the large amount of drippings and how dangerous it can be to take it out of the oven. However, a shallow roasting pan (considered to be 1-2 inches deep) is perfect for roasting chicken, vegetables or other cuts of meat besides turkey.

How do you Clean Roasting Pans?

Some roasting pans are dishwasher safe which means you can just remove the drippings and most of the grease and then put them in. If not, to clean a roasting pan, soak the pan in warm soapy water and scrub. If it doesn’t remove the residue, sprinkle baking soda in the pan and then add a mixture of 1/3 cup vinegar plus one cup of hot water.

Should you Cover your Turkey When Roasting?

Place your turkey in the oven, uncovered and let it cook. However, if it’s getting too brown too quickly, then you can either baste it or cover your turkey with a loose foil tent. If specific parts like the legs are getting too dark, cover that specific part with a small piece of foil.

How do you Use a Roasting Pan with Lid?

There are a few steps to follow to use a roasting pan:

1. Put the rack into your roasting pan
2. Season your meat
3. Put the meat on the rack
4. Put the roaster pan in the center of a hot oven
5. Cover the meat with a lid or tented foil cover
6. Cook until the desired or required internal temperature
7. Take the meat out and allow to rest for 5-10 minutes before carving

Do you Have to Put Water in a Roaster Pan?

It’s not recommend to put water in a roaster pan because it defeats the purpose of it and will steam your food, not roast it. However, if the bottom is dry and you want some drippings for gravy, add a little bit of water in the last 10 minutes of cooking.

What Can You Cook in a Roasting Pan?

You can cook lots of things in a roasting pan. Some of the most popular options include:

• Roasted meats
• Turkey or whole chickens
• Braised meats, poultry or veggies
• Roasted potatoes
• Other vegetables
• Large batches of lasagna, shepherd’s pie or fruit cobbler
• Water bath for custards or souffles

Are Enamel Roasting Pans Safe?

Enamel roasting pans are safe as they don’t break down at high temperature. This makes then an ideal choice for roasting pans, along with stainless steel or cast iron. It’s also for this same reason that Teflon is not a good choice for a roaster pan.

Is a Roasting Pan the Same as a Baking Dish?

Roasting pans and baking dishes are not the same. A roasting pan usually has a rack whereas baking dishes do not. Baking dishes usually come with a lid while roasting pans may not. Finally, roasting pans are more likely to have a nonstick coating than a baking dish does.

Is a Broiler Pan the Same as a Roasting Pan?

Broiler pans are not the same as a roasting pan. Broiling pans are shallow and have a slotted base while roaster pans are deeper. The purpose of a broiling pan is to cook food quickly and allow dripping to drain from the meat, while roasting pans (if you don’t use the rack) allow the meat to cook in its own juices.

Have your Say about the Best Roasting Pan

What’s your top pick for a roaster pan, or a turkey roasting pan? Is it one of the options from this list, or do you have your eye on another brand? Leave a comment below and let us know what you think. We’d love to hear from you.

Also be sure to give this article a share on Facebook, Pinterest, or Twitter. It’ll help other busy home cooks, like yourself find this useful resource.

Last update on 2021-04-09 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API